Policy Is Boring (NOT!)

What do policymakers want from researchers? Blogs, elevator pitches and good old fashioned press mentions.

Duncan Green provides short and sweet translations of some of the key findings from a recent survey looking at how US policymakers use and value international studies research. The findings point to the importance of blogging, but also to the sustained influence of traditional print media.

I cast a ‘not nearly’ wide enough net in my daily fieldwalks through my browser, but it is wide enough to pick up some interesting stuff that resonates on a different frequency than my usually beat of edtech, connected learning, and composition tools.

I came across this in my RSS feed (Inoreader) and could not help but see adjacent possibilities flash before me. Duncan Green makes an open invitation to anyone out there who could be seen as big time, informal policy experts. I see his blog post as a call to our students at university (and younger) to become expert in at least some aspect of their discipline (or their lives) as it applies to social policy. I, too,  see this as an acknowledgement of a growing sphere of influence for credible outsiders and iconoclasts. In other words, this is a clarion trumpet blast for readers and writers to become expert readers and writers. If this is not a supreme justification for liberal arts principles and values I don’t know what is.

Green identifies some of these adjacent opportunities in this post. His comments are in bold below and mine are in block quotes.

1. The more policymakers know about a subject, the less they believe ‘experts’.

What I know well, I can suss out so-called experts on. If they are nuanced, I know it. If they are not, then usually that is a sign they don’t know their stuff. Not always, but usually. So, I want experts who know their stuff summing up, critiquing, curating, and analyzing research materials so I don’t have to. And I want to be able to trust them so I am so burdened with fact checking them.

2. Get blogging, people.

Folks who are visible and have been for a long time have greater credibility. For example, someone like Bryan Alexander has cred for me. When he writes about higher ed I read it. There are real opportunities for writers who can grow in expertise through blogging. Policymakers need bloggers to help them and, apparently, familiarity and trust trump academic standing. Good news for outsiders and iconoclasts.

3. Work on those elevator pitches.

Outsider information can rocketh even in the face of inside game “classified” channels. But…the internet is still viewed as suspect or perhaps a bit of a diluted authority. Elite print still wins.

4. Good old fashioned press work beats social media.

There is a growing role for those who could become authoritative experts online and guides on the side. These senior policy folks don’t want or need to be ‘educated or trained’. What they need are advisers and sharers of new knowledge. Most of all thy want “frames” from which facts and new knowledge can be made sense of. In other words”the best narrative (not the best evidence) wins”.

 

a pie graph that shows learning sources for policy makers
How policymakers view their own learning sources

 

As an aside, I find the pie graph cited in Green’s piece to be very revealing and a corroboration of adult/informal research work done by folks like Charles Jennings  known in learning and development theory as the “70-20-10 model”.

At the P-20 levels our policymakers are considered typically to be the administrators.  The open and startling truth of this graph is that 50% of real, useable learning comes from field work, but the hidden truth is I think what this means to teachers and students. We are all potential hyperlocal policymakers and the adjacent possibility here is that fat and untapped channel of policymaking that could rise up from the everyday field of ‘classroom’ work.

How could we cultivate this unacknowledged field?  Start by admitting that it exists, then begin to develop simple, easy to use ways to tap into the flow or to use existing channels (social media, email, online communities) to do so.  If we don’t, then we still have the status quo with its secret backchannels and old boy/old girl networks.  Yeah, how’s that been working for us?

I want to think more about how this applies at all levels of the educational establishment. I would love to know whether it could or already does constitute a separate path, a countervailing force within the establishment institution. What do you think?

Duncan Green’s piece was published in his blog From Poverty to Power.Green has also written a book by the same title. His twitter handle is @fp2p.

We Are Boundary Catalysts

paper theater as tool for creative visualization
Visual Facilitation Theater

I think Sarah Honeychurch was remarking that “catalyst” was one of her favorite words. Mine, too.  Then I ran across this blog post by Chris Glynn and knew I had hit a very rich vein that I could share with her.  Here is the quote that thrilled me and I hope you like it, too, because I think it represents one of the those disciplinary crossover moves.  What I mean is I am going to steal this idea to motivate myself and maybe you can as well.

Illustrators are like actors, teachers and politicians: we are boundary catalysts, able to engage with emotionally charged, strategic, learning situations. Illustrators have always been interpreters and translators. However, in addition to illuminating a text or idea from within, or commenting from the side-lines, or speaking for others from a brief, we can take the main stage and occupy an expanded role by hosting, influencing and directing the conversation, and animating the exchange of energy and ideas.

Job description anyone? Teacher as Illustrator? I like it.

Note: this post has Hypothes.is annotation extras in the side margin. Feel free to add your own annotations. You don’t even need to ask permisson, just have at it, hoss.

The Whole World Is A DJ

I ran across this quote reading a forum here on how to keep your mixes from getting booted off Soundcloud.

The whole world is a DJ

In the context of that forum the point was that the tools are available now for almost anyone to begin to be their own DJ, but there is real consonance and dissonance in that short declarative sentence.

This collage is my first take on exploring it.  If you go here you can add your own to it, remix or de-mix.

Ladybug Baby Shower Ideas Photo Collage

Here is my own annotation of it.

thewholeworldisdj

Why bother with this ‘hyperactivity’? I am interested in the play of text and image. As a teacher and especially as a teacher of composition I feel it is part of my discipline and work to explore the metes and bounds of these media. What happens when they cross each other. Is there a hedgerow effect where text and words get all weedy and messy together just as they do in a fencerow? Is it like the various DMZ’s around the world that end up being profoundly diverse ecocorridors for diversity to expand into? Is it even like an ecosystem at all? All of these questions and more all go toward answering the larger pedagogic one: if text and image and sound are an ecosystem, then how can those who are learning along with me make the most of their own ‘mess’? I love my work.

Please note: there are some notes in the margins created by Hypothes.is. You are welcome to join me there where you will find explanatory screencasts, snarky endeavors by colleagues, and much and sundry: https://via.hypothes.is/http://impedagogy.com/wp/blog/2016/07/21/the-whole-world-is-a-dj/