I wrote this letter to a colleague this morning. I don’t know why I don’t embrace the epistolary style more often in writing blog posts. I feel like all my posts are to my few but fine audience.
I have always considered ideas like this as pandering and the death knell for the university, but I am changing my mind. It would take almost no effort to transform my comp classes into microcredential classes. For example, instead of teaching E100, I might have a comp class where I might teach the following among other things:
1. How to summarize a journal article
2. How to create a useable research question
3. How to interview someone online
4. Using Zotero as a research tool
5. How to critique an argument
6. A zillion other processes, skills, and concepts to be learned and combined
There would be no grades, only credentials or no credentials. You could combine this with MIT’s blockchain credentialling system to get a whole new way for students to earn cred. The useful thing about this is that even students who drop out might earn something for their money instead of nothing.
It is not hard to look at a syllabus and do this. I worry about gen ed as a sustainable model. I would love to work with CITL on a pilot of this in the classroom. Unfortunately, this kind of alternative learning model, like the C19 virus, would be deeply subversive, but it might be what the university needs to survive another millenium. Just wanted to do a little blue sky moment while I was thinking on it because I knew you might be an attentive ear. Thanks.
Seek, Make Sense of, and Share with Alison McDowell
I love the “responsive activity” (as my buddy @dogtrax calls it) of digital annotation, but I have a big concern with the kinds of writing others choose for us to mark up. It seems to be dominated by the cold fish jargon of ‘aca-speak’. These chosen texts gives me only an abstraction of feeling, hollowed out and brittle. I prefer to engage with plain writing, plain feeling, and plain doing instead of being distanced from feeling. Speaking of…
I would love to have a conversation with anyone who is interested in a future of learning that is not all about “data-mining, human resourcing, and social impact investment opportunities.” Or as Alison McDowell puts it: education for liberation, less data, more Freire.
I especially direct her work to Daniel Bassill because of all the work he does with maps and mapping as well as Kevin Hodgson with his recent twitter viz. McDowell uses a visualization tool called “Oligrapher”. This mapping tech is part of an organization called LittleSis.
LittleSis is offering a Zoom Training for January 7, 2020 for those interested in an introduction to Oligrapher. Sign up, become a member, and then sign up for the online training. I hope Dan and Kevin can join me to keep me honest, but I would love to meet other interested parties there as well. I am going to use this tool to do some investigative work on my campus and in my department about corporate connections here (read Blackboard, Zoom, and more). Might want to use this tool to look at the money pit that is my local Congressperson, Brett Guthrie. He needeth a paddling in the public stocks. Might also want to look at all the corporate and foundation connections that the NWP has embraced in recent years for funding projects
This flurry of activity is due entirely to my discovery of the work of concerned parent/citizen Alison McDowell. It is an understatement to say that her blog, Wrench in the Gears: A Skeptical Parent’s Thoughts on Digital Curriculum, is a revelation.
She is spreading the word face-to-face as well as on YouTube. I have been listening to and watching one long, but super-fruitful video she gave in Kent, Washington. I have taken that video and embedded it into Vialogues, a tool for annotating videos. You can lurk and view the annotations, but you can also join Vialogues for free (it’s part of Columbia University) and pile onto the annotations. I have embedded the Vialogue of McDowell’s talk below. I think this is profound stuff and critically important for learning, especially learning that is ‘unbought’ by corporations.
I have just begun taking an online course from the Association of College and University Educators (ACUE) offered this spring and summer titled “Effective Teaching Practices”. It is way better than I thought it would be and it offers many techniques to help students learn including the ones listed below:
Increase intrinsic motivation
Offer choice when appropriate (group projects, assignments, assessments)
Provide tools for targeted improvement (rubrics, checklists, writing samples)
Offer specific and timely feedback
Offer opportunities to use feedback for revision
Connect learning to career or other long-term goals
Foster a sense of belonging to an online course community
Demonstrate the connection between increased effort and improved performance
Communicate how increased effort leads to improved performance
Praise students for effort as opposed to natural ability
Offer specific praise connected to effort
Use grades to communicate progress
Use grades to diagnose what students know and what they need to work on
Provide time management strategies and regular reminders
Send messages of encouragement and support.”
Most of us practice these quite intentionally. For example, I have been using weekly goal setting and reflection in my E100 and E300classes the past two school years alongside their semester-long research paper. My plan has been to get them to “plan their work and work their plan”. That motto is from a previous lifetime when I owned a chimney-cleaning business. If I hadn’t followed that motto, I would not have been able to make ends meet. The truth in it is nothing new, but I found that students did not know how to set goals for long-term projects. And what I learned in those two years was two-fold: (1). I had a hard time teaching them how to set those goals and (2) they had a hard time working those limited plans.
Fast forward to Spring 2019 and my ACUE course. I ran into a tool there that would help me with both teaching how to plan and with my students learning how to work their plans. It has a silly acronym, DAPPS. Here’s a site where you can read the ACUE document https://nowcomment.com/documents/133206 (and comment if you wish).
Most of the research that I have read in this course argues that motivation comes with the success of doing the work in small steps. That is the opposite of the usual, ‘rahrahrah’ line that suggests we have to motivate first, then find success. I have found that the motivation comes from making promises to yourself that you keep. (Ready-fire-aim not ready-aim-fire.) What DAPPS does is allow you to fine tune your goals into manageable pieces by demanding that they be time specific, task specific, personal, positive (as in what you want not what you don’t want), and achievable.
Student goals are none of these at first. This is a model that has to be taught and it has to be followed throughout the semester. That is what I failed to do in previous semesters. I gave up on the work plans and their weekly reflections after a while. I just thought they got it. At the end their writings showed me they hadn’t.
Here’s is what I am doing now with the addition of DAPPS.
I use the work plan as a way to generate topics
Next, I ask them to create research questions from those topics
Then, we begin to seek answers to those questions through a wide-ranging research process (online and face-to-face)
This is when I apply the DAPPS format so that their research is focussed as noted above
I ask them to reflect on their research plans each Sunday
Lastly, they create a new work plan on Monday using DAPPS as their rubric.
Wash-rinse-repeat.
Before Spring Break we began to apply this model much more rigorously. I created a work plan for myself that we applied the DAPPS format to in class. I used their suggestions to create a revised work plan that is way more useful. The amazing thing was that it really was better. I think they helped me see improvements that might have been in my blind spot. I have attached the before and after files so that you can see the difference.
Original work plan:
Revised work plan:
I am marking up my student’s plans even now and I hope they have discovered what a handy tool this is.
Final note: the final exam in this class will be to write a summative essay on the process they followed to create their research project. This will come directly from the reflections they have done every Sunday in response to their weekly work plans. I really am looking forward to this big reflection.