Without Deviation from the Known, No Progress Is Possible.

stepping off
I made the observations below responding with some Diigo annotations to Cathleen Nardi’s post “Down the Rabbit Hole”.  She notes that
To make changes in education, we must embrace uncertainty in our teaching, and we must help our students understand that it is ok not to have the right answer.  The quest —the leap into the unknown is the learning process.
Here is my response.
It is unnatural to leap into the total darkness of the unknown. In fact I think that by definition it is impossible. Instead I think we leap into the partly known. My analogy is the Kentucky pioneer Daniel Boone. Some might say that he worked his way into virgin, unknown territory. I would say yes and no. He did blaze trails into places no Euro-American had ever been, but the territory itself shared lots of known traits with where he had already been. For example, water flows downhill to larger streams. The sun rises in the east. And the thousand other ‘knowns’ that come from a lifetime of living close to ground. And, of course, he really did blaze the trails he made by walking. He emblazened trees with marks for others to follow. Now that must’ve been an ego trip and a half!
The other half of the analogy is that we too have general knowledge that we take with us into the knowmadic life and the rhizomatic wilderness of learning. We have theoretical knowledge. I would include the whole baggage of ed school in that. But we have to dump most of that when we move into the partly known territory of deep, rhizomatic knowmadicism. You need to travel light when you are blazing the trail. You need the practical stuff in your backpack.

All week and every week I will be bringing back news as I light out into the territories. I expect to get well and truly turned around on occasion, but I don’t plan on backtracking much except to send back reports. Boone wasn’t much good at this part, but Lewis and Clark were, but I daresay I call more on the Kentuckian than I do the Virginian. All I know is that every one who reads this could be  a real guide to the undiscovered country. This week and in this post Cathleen Nardi was my Sacagewea.  Amen.

 

cropped-cat-profile-2013equal signsacagewa

 

If anyone is interested here is a Diigo annotation of Cathleen’s entire post:  https://diigo.com/01jjko .And if anyone wants a deep dive, minicourse in what Cathleen is writing about, I pulled out all the links she mentions and put them into the Diigo link as well in a standalone sticky note.

#Rhizo14: Conformity and Iconoclasm

Dave Cormier’s intro to rhizo14 is full with translation.  Or rather it is full with the invitation to translate.  By that I mean he gives us room to begin to come to terms with “rhizomatic learning’.  Below I begin totranslate  a few of his choice remarks.

What happens if we let go of the conventional idea of a course directed from the top down?

I think that there are layers of letting go. There is the primary one Dave describes in the first paragraph–an aware sloughing off of the skin of coursework and curriculum and student and teacher and syllabus–the whole catastrophe. This is very hard unlearning. It requires a continuous monitoring of old metaphors and thinking in the light of …well, you know not what. The secondary letting go is individual baggage schema we each prize. We call it experience. It is an even greater unlearning. It is the matter of taking to heart  Coleridge’s  “willing suspension of disbelief” in ways that most of us are unwilling to risk. We say we can do it, but such work is perceived as dangerous. It requires a vulnerability to and presence of the immediate, unmediated now. That is some scary shit, compadre, I don’t mind saying. 

Trust the idea that people can come together to learn given the availability of an abundance of perspective, of information and of connection?

We are quite capable of doing this. We just have to remember what it was like to be an infant learning once more. Yeah, just open up a vein while you’re at it. I will try, but how do I try to do this? (No Yoda quotes in response, please.)  First, I have to accept as given that everyone has best intentions at heart. That means that I have to have the very best intentions myself. Not perfect, but the best that I can muster. Second, I have to bring immediate and vulnerable stuff to the table. That means no bullshit to the best of my ability. Or even better, I will be honest. For example, I am trying to be straightforward about my worries here and about what I expect of myself and what I expect of others. And I have to acknowledge that I might be wrong, yes, totally wrong about all or part of what I have already written.

Being resident in a particular field?

As a farmer, I am comfortable with the idea of working in a field. I acknowledge that there are pre-existent, but not largely predetermined paths. I understand that there is mystery here black swanand ‘unknown unknowns’ that can play out like Taleb’s black swans–complex, unbidden and unpredictable. As a farmer, I know that I am always working behind the arc of the future, a future that is as often as not curling and ready to collapse in gnarly waves crushing or carrying me forward into the present and then the past.

The class is made up of the collected paths chosen by all the students, shaped by my influence as an instructor and the impact of those external nodes they manage to contact.  Respond.

I am simultaneously the best conformist and worst iconoclast I know of. I have had plenty of practice at doing what I am told. Plenty. At the same time I have found it quite impossible to do so. For example, my wife and I homebirthed all of our children in a time and place where finding midwives was a challenge. There were no certified nurse midwives where we lived. In fact, even getting a physician to help with pre-natal care was problematic. We eventually found exceptional help on the margins. Our midwife had gotten her training and experience working in Texas with very poor folks exactly like us. Our midwife’s assistant opened up a world of knowledge that we didn’t know existed. Our firstborn had some interesting complications including a cord wrapped around the neck.  My point is simple–I suspect we only became iconoclasts because flickr-196686028-original.jpg (1440×1080)the issue is so personal and important, so important that we could not leave the work entirely to experts. Just like we could not leave our kids’ learning to the not so tender ministrations of schools, public or private, so we homeschooled. Just like we couldn’t leave our food and water and housing entirely to others. I am hoping to meet iconoclasts and conformists alike to help me meet this term with open hands.

Course starts January 14th

I must get past my personal iconoclasm to get to the community. This will be hard for me. I have some experience last summer working with some fabulous folks from the National Writing Project. They took me on and I learned how to national writing project - Google Searchconnect better. That community-centeredness is not foreign to me, but it has not always been the way I have gotten along best in the world. I love helping every Tom, Jane, and Harry, but I really don’t like institutional groups all that much. I shy away from Rotarians and churches alike. Rhizo14 will be part of my continuing effort to get out of my comfort zone. I will need all the help I can get.

[If you want to know more about iconoclasm in coding, check out Ted Neward’s Info Q keynote.]

 

David Price’s Most Excellent Questions about the Future of Learning

Have schools been centered on the institutional and personal imperatives of educators and not learners?
How colleges and universities adapt to the customization and personalization of education will largely determine their survival.
Will higher education adapt to the challenge of customization/personalization? How will they do so? Is this the creative dislocation of our time?

Is the MOOC analogous to an mp3? Are they potentially as disruptive to higher ed as mp3’s were to the music industry?

Have schools had a monopoly on learning? Or have they had a monopoly on authenticating that learning?

Will this be for everyone or only for those who can be autodidacts? Are we all natural autodidacts?

Once students have learned to hack their own education, what will happen to traditional models of high school and higher education?

 

What is the purpose of schools in the ecosystem where it lives in a similar niche as social media? Do they provide a set of skilled employees for the labor market? Are they about developing the ‘whole’ child – emotionally, intellectually, creatively?
Here to serve to ensure national economic competitiveness? Are they about civic cohesion through cultural education?
Is it true that if we can’t agree on a purpose or purposes for school then we can’t possibly get where we want to go?

Addressing teachers in 2012, Heng Swee Keat, Singapore’s Minister for Education, argued for a radical shift in policy:

 “The educational paradigm of our parents’ generation, which emphasized the transmission of knowledge, is quickly being overtaken by a very different paradigm. This new concept of educational success focuses on the nurturing of key skills and competencies such as the ability to seek, to curate and to synthesize information; to create and innovate; to work in diverse cross-cultural teams; as well as to appreciate global issues within the local context.”
Is Singapore’s Minister of Education right? Is there a new paradigm today? Is he right that we need to teach competencies like seek/sense/share, creating and innovating, collaborating, and being a global citizen?

South Korea’s ex-minister for education Byong Man Ahn cast doubt on the usefulness of a high PISA ranking, despite Korean students ranking first in reading and maths, and third in science, in the 2009 PISA survey:

“While Korea‘s students excel at learning, they believe its purpose lies not in self-development based on personal interest or motivation, but in entrance into a highly ranked university. Students have no time to ponder the fundamental question of “What do I need to learn, and why?” They simply need to prepare for the test by learning the most-effective methods for digesting tremendous quantities of material and committing more to memory than others do.”

Is the PISA exam just another example of the quants gone amok? On tap or on top?