Which Side Are You On, Boys, Which Side Are You On?

I just lost a post where I tried to explain how learning is a natural state of being baked into our DNA and that teaching is actually training in disguise.

I argued that most of the solutions we propose as teachers within the system are iatrogenic, self-inflicted problems which require half-baked, dumbed-down teacherly solutions.

I asserted that learning is not a solution because learning is not a problem. Teaching and schooling are the problem.

I asked the question, “What kind of assumptions can we make about a system that does not believe that learning is a natural expression of our core natures?” Put another way, if we have to make people learn, what does that imply about our learning selves?

I said all this much better in the lost post. I am sorry this is all that is left.

It is hard to work within such a divided house. Lincoln asserted that such a house cannot stand. So the question remains unanswered, “Have we enslaved our better natures?” This only begs the question inspired by Florence Reece, the wife of Sam Reece, a union organizer for the United Mine Workers in Harlan County, Kentucky, “Which side are you on?” Play the song below and ask yourself.

YouTube player

And the question for me? Which runs deeper, my courage or my fear?

Saturday Morning at Zero: A Sufi Parable

In one of the great court banquets, everyone was
seated according to rank, waiting the entry of the King. In came a plain, shabby man and took a seat above everyone else. His boldness angered the prime minister who ordered the newcomer to identify himself. Was he a minister? No. More. Was he the King? No. More. “Are you then God?” asked the prime minister. “I am above that also,” replied the poor man. “There is nothing beyond God,” retorted the prime minister. “That nothing,” came the response, “is me” (Carse 3).

Carse, James P. Breakfast at the Victory: The Mysticism of Ordinary Experience. Revised ed. edition. San Francisco, Calif.: HarperOne, 1995. Print.

YouTube player