Certainly I’m Wrong

singlenoise

Just finished reading Venkatesh Rao’s newsletter “Breaking Smart”.

It is a breath of honest air even if it sometimes stinks of the fishmonger, hangovers, and last night’s tuna surprise. I know that doesn’t sound like much of a recommendation, but I can count on my hands the sources of honest,fearless ‘un-niceness’ and this is one of them. Buyer be aware, reader beware.

When I read Rao I always come away with new wrenches to cast into the works (or I pull out ones that Rao has tossed into mine).  For example, I have been thrashing around on my posts all week to come to terms in some effective way with the idea of TMI and filtering information.  Along comes Rao, molotov in hand, and he argues that filtering is an illusion depending upon which consensus is being manufactured. And,what’s even more problematic, with the “never-forgetting” character of the internet, nothing is ever thrown away.  It is just paid attention to differently.

Here are several of his other monkey wrenches:

Cupcake fascism
Derping
Manufactured normalcy

So, my way of curating Rao is to ask you to read his newsletter in its entirety, perhaps explore previous newsletters, consider the quote image below, and hyperlink out of here for a sidetrip of trippy and scary ideas. Nor narrowing the signal, am I. Thanks, Obama.

 

Beautiful Curatorial Noise? IDK.

e0c228138a2faecc6bcd85f17ddc9c9b

In my last post I wrote about how much noise was generated in my email from just five newsletters. I have always thought that curation by others would help create a signal, but it appears to me that just a few degrees of separation creates a botheration of beautiful, curatorial noise. Of course, I could always choose to create quiet. That seems a cop out, an abdication of what I consider part of my duty as a “concierge” for my readers and my learners. Take two more examples in my Sunday email.

Audrey Watters’ Hack Education Weekly Newsletter (HEWN)

I am not critiquing this newsletter. I am trying to look more reflectively at how I ‘consume’ its hyperlinkage and how I curate those links for others. And I have to say that I do it mostly willy nilly. If it interests me, I bring it into my network share spaces and if I don’t it disappears in the Google of my email. I do have some filters. I might find something that I know an online buddy might be interested in. I might find a link that I know I am interested in and it heads to other choice database black holes (Diigo/Zotero/Pinterest/Scoop.it/et al). Those give me the semblance of control as I promise to return to them later for reconsideration. I think of this as filtering after the fact. I mean, really, I found this shiny object and can’t possibly give it up.

My best filtering comes ‘before the fact’. What I mean by that is that I create a guiding question that is as specific as I can make it. For example, I am working with my students right now with a research question on how, as a farmer, I can take a two week vacation. The question provides keyword filters that get me going in various search spaces online and off. It is a guiding filter that changes as I curate what the keywords bring to me. I use a template to gather the information in one spot and then I make sense of it.

That kind of curation is from the inside out rather than vice versa. But I still have a whole curatorial life that is trying to come to terms with the FOMO that drives me to bring ever more info into my curatorial spaces, from the outside in.  Information like Katexic provides:

What does this mean?  As someone who hopes to teach students how to gather, make sense of, and share with others, it is very important to be clear about this thing that is a hyperlink.  Is it some stupid thing that does something when you click it, like a light switch? Or is a hyperlink much more than a thing, with meaning in and of itself, social and psychological and spiritual?

Because I live in nature on a farm in the hills and hollars, I am always comparing the work of my discipline with Nature.  Is my relationship with the hyperlink an organic one much like the relationship that a tree has with fungi?  Or is it just a wannabe organic relationship? Is a hyperlink a symbiote?  IDK.  The rising complexity of the hyperlink intertwingled with my own life along with the idea that no hyperlink is more than a few degrees of separation from any other makes me think that a complex system is arising from the simple initial condition of the hyperlink. Like flocking behavior in birds or schooling behavior in fish.

If it is organic and symbiotic, then what is that relationship doing to us and our brains.  Is the hyperlink jumping the brain’s blood barrier and infecting our neural systems in ways that have a deep epigenetic effect right now? IDK.

I do know that I have grown uncomfortable with the massive collections of hyperlinks that accrue to me from newsletters.  I feel obliged to curate them.  I feel that by doing so I am only adding to other folks’ duty to view and curate further.  Noise on top of noise, the ultimate digital Babel.   What to do?  IDK.

idk

I Contradict Myself Very Well

From Leaves of Grass:

The past and present wilt — I have fill’d them, emptied them,
And proceed to fill my next fold of the future.

Listener up there! what have you to confide to me?
Look in my face while I snuff the sidle of evening,
(Talk honestly, no one else hears you, and I stay only a
minute longer.)

Do I contradict myself?
Very well then I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes.)

I concentrate toward them that are nigh, I wait on the door-slab.

Who has done his day’s work? who will soonest be through
with his supper?
Who wishes to walk with me?

Will you speak before I am gone? will you prove already too
late?

52

The spotted hawk swoops by and accuses me, he complains
of my gab and my loitering.

I too am not a bit tamed, I too am untranslatable,
I sound my barbaric yawp over the roofs of the world.

Uncle Walty captures the natural and upsetting equivocation that makes me what I am.Here are two articles that touch upon this contradition very deeply.

Andrew Sullivan: My Distraction Sickness – and Yours

And this one as very well,

Journalist’s Toolbox | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

Charm A companion app for iOS that helps you “organize Tweets into collections, save articles for later, cue up playlists of music you find, or transcribe conversations. You can use it to tell stories, hold on to jokes, capture Tweetstorms and monologues. Charm has features to curate Tweets from events you’re watching, too.”

One draws me ‘into’ while the other pushes me ‘out of’.

“They are both maelstroms,” I say with a yawp both untamed and untranslateable. Both are untamed and untameable.

Out to the pastures to feed and water the sheep and take photos of them and share them online. Multitudes. We contain multitudes. Maelstroms of multitudes, untamed and untameable.

We could drown.So swim or grab onto something that floats by.