Re-framing “Plagiarism” as Learning

The French blogger Lionel Dricot (AKA Ploum) has some useful advice for uni teachers who are struggling with plagiarism on tests and assignments–reframe them as learning.

Here is a summing up: let students choose by showing them how to change.

Students use chatbots in their everyday lives so we should teach them to use these tools responsibly in those everyday lives especially in school.

The Problem

Many schools either ban chatbots outright or act as if they don’t exist. Both responses miss the point that:

  • Students are already using these tools.

  • AI tools are not going away.

  • Digital literacy in the workaday world now includes knowing how to work with AI.

Rather than trying to see if a chatbot could pass the test, Ploum’s goal was to help students learn how to use the tools responsibly.


The Experiment: Student Choice

Before the exam, students had to pick one of two options.

Option A – No Chatbots

  • Only traditional research methods (like web searches) are allowed.

  • Any chatbot use would count as cheating.

Option B – Chatbots Allowed (With Rules)
Students could use a chatbot only if they followed strict rules:

  • Transparency: clearly state when information comes from a chatbot.

  • Share the exact prompts they used.

  • Identify and explain any mistakes in the chatbot’s answers.

Breaking any of those rules would be treated as cheating.


The Accountability Rule

If a student chose to use a chatbot, they were fully responsible for its output.

Chatbot mistakes were penalized more heavily than ordinary human mistakes.Why? Using a powerful tool requires careful judgment and extra verification. In other words, you can use the tool, but you can’t blame it for unchecked errors–you are accountable for what it produces.


What Students Learn

Ploum argues that this approach shifts the focus from banning technology to teaching responsibility and includes these lessons. (They are supposed to learn, right?)

  • Be transparent. Show your sources and your process.

  • Think critically. AI outputs must be checked and evaluated.

  • Don’t outsource thinking. Tools can help, but they don’t replace reasoning.

  • Make choices deliberately. Deciding in advance whether to use a tool forces you to think about how you learn.


Why It Matters for Education

This experiment reframes the debate. It’s less about catching students in some punitive ‘gotcha’ game and more about preparing them for a world that already uses all of these powerful tools.

Education should adapt by raising expectations for responsibility and judgment—not by lowering standards.


The Bigger Question

Can we design learning environments where using powerful tools requires even stronger thinking?

Ploum suggests we can. I think so, too. The larger question I ask myself is this:  why did I not do this just before I retired I could have made a big difference for my colleagues and learners?

I think we all know why?  Change is dangerous and revolutionary change is the most dangerous.  The danger is to how we make our bread and butter, to the status quo, to the schema we have already invested so much energy to laying down in our hearts and minds.

File under eating my own “dog food”, i.e. practicing what I preach:

  • Transparency: I used ChatGPT

  • Prompt used: Turn this post into a one page teaching brief that is readable by a high school student.

  • Mistakes or edits: I edited for excessive dumbing down and for unnecessary formatting

M. L. Rio’s to Beat “Resistance”

 

Artist M.L. Rio is just like the rest of us who create–sometimes she needs a little help, a nudge toward the possible on this Winter’s Solstice darkest day. Consider this your quiet gift of a hip check into the creative lane.

Overcoming Creative Obstacles (Writer’s Block)

When wrestling with writer’s block, Rio uses practical strategies, often relating to shifting focus or lowering expectations:

1. Treat Writing as a Job: Rio emphasizes that if writing is a career, you gotta do the time.  “Clock in and do your time,” even if the work feels difficult, forcing oneself to continue even when it “sucks”.
2. Use Physical Movement: To get her brain moving, Rio prioritizes physical movement. She believes that if she gets her body moving (like taking a walk or going to the gym), the brain will follow, and she often brainstorms while exercising.
3. Engage with External Art: When stuck, Rio makes sure to “feed her creative wellspring” by engaging with other people’s art. This includes activities such as going to a concert, visiting a museum, or reading a book that is not her own, which helps “grease the wheels and get stuff moving”.
4. Deliberately Write a Bad Version: As a last resort, Rio will intentionally write the worst version of the material she possibly can. This process is described as “very liberating” because it removes the stakes, ensuring she at least ends up with something, a zero draft at the least. By turning off her own “taste filter,” she often finds her way back into the flow, and her good writer instincts kick in after a couple of pages.

Enhancing Artistic Quality and Depth

Rio uses “intensive, holistic methods” to enhance the depth, realism, and visceral quality of her narratives. What the hell does that entail? See below:

1. Visceral and Sensory Writing: Rio describes herself as a “very visceral, physical writer” who aims to write books that feel so immersive readers can “climb inside them and live there”. To achieve this, she likes to write using all five senses.
2. Immersive On-Location Research: To ensure an accurate sense of place, especially in narratives with multiple locations, Rio finds it crucial to “get boots on the ground and really know what you’re talking about”. For the complete rewrite of Hot Wax, she sold her house and lived out of her car for 18 months, driving around, visiting research locations, and writing in places like roadside diners.
3. Prioritize Mundane Details: To counteract the tendency of fiction (especially about music or theater) to romanticize these worlds, Rio highlighted the importance of including mundane details. She deliberately made *Hot Wax* a “gross book” that is sweaty, gritty, grimy, and “reeking of cigarettes and hairspray and beer” to represent the truth of the world as she experienced it.
4. Use Music as Point Zero: Music is the “point zero” of her writing process, regardless of the book’s topic. She continuously compiles a “master tapes” soundtrack playlist during the writing and rewriting process that captures the overall “vibe of the book”.
5. Reject Expectations and Embrace the “Weird Shit”: After receiving industry feedback that her previous work wasn’t “literary enough” and that her writing (as a woman) needed to be quiet and subtle, Rio found that enhancing her artistic quality required resisting those norms. Encouraged by an editor to make Hot Wax “bigger and louder and weirder and more obnoxious,” she realized she needed permission to “do the weird shit,” which ultimately made the book work.
6. Holistic Writing Definition: Rio adopts a holistic view of writing, defining it beyond just putting new words on paper. Her process includes outlining, revision, marketing, research (driven by her PhD background), and spending time in her “discovery space” her mindscape.

So I am taking these  days between Winter Solstice and New Year’s Day to apply some or most of Rio’s advice.  Let me know if you want to meet for an adhoc short discussion on how to apply these to a kernel of a creative seed. Maybe it will sprout.

 

Summaries AI and Otherwise

A marvelous interview with Crow artist Wendy Red Star.  You might think of it as a mini-course in creativity with Wendy as the case study.

Here are some interesting quotes from the text:

– “Authenticity Can Be Found in the Artificial.”
– “Starting out being a poor grad student, I had to think of how I could do something big with the budget that I had.”
– “Constraints and Scarcity Are Powerful Catalysts.”
– “You should always bet on yourself. It always turns out well, making that investment.”
– “The Real Work Often Happens Outside the Studio.”
– “The most important part of the process might not be visible to an outside observer.”
– “True Creative Maturity Is Collaborative.”
– “As I’ve moved into a more mature practice, the thing that’s been really pleasurable is how collaborative it is… It’s just been so much more fantastic than I could ever imagine.”
– “Research Is a Conversation with Your Ancestors.”

And here are some ideas for writing:

1. **Astroturf Dreams: The Authenticity of the Artificial**
– Explore the juxtaposition of real and artificial in art, drawing parallels to Wendy Red Star’s use of dioramas.

2. **The Elk Tooth Dress: Symbols of Adaptation**
– A poem reflecting on cultural resourcefulness and the symbolism of imitation teeth, exploring the deeper meanings of authenticity.

3. **Constraints as Catalyst: The Gift of Scarcity**
– Delve into how limitations can fuel creativity, inspired by Red Star’s experiences as a single mother and artist.

4. **Between 7 P.M. and 1 A.M.: A Time for Creation**
– Capture the nocturnal world of an artist who finds time in the quiet hours, turning scarcity into productivity.

5. **The Invisible Studio: Where Ideas Bloom**
– A meditation on the unseen labor of creativity, where research and conceptualization lay the groundwork for art.

6. **Collaborative Canvas: The Maturity of Shared Vision**
– Celebrate the evolution from solitary creation to the joy of collaboration, inspired by Red Star’s artistic journey.

7. **Ancestral Whispers: Research as Dialogue**
– Explore the concept of research as a conversation with ancestors, where intuition guides the discovery of hidden stories.

8. **Chief Plenty Coups in Washington: A Journey of Influence**
– Narrate the historical travels of Chief Plenty Coups, weaving together cultural exchange and personal transformation.

9. **The Mount Vernon Connection: A Cross-Cultural Landscape**
– Examine the blend of cultural landscapes, inspired by Chief Plenty Coups’ admiration for George Washington’s estate.

10. **Redefining Creativity: A Path Uniquely Yours**
– A reflective piece on letting go of romanticized myths to embrace a more grounded and personal artistic path.

11. **Betting on Yourself: The Leap into the Unknown**
– Inspire readers with the courage to take risks, drawing from Red Star’s decision to pursue full-time artistry.

12. **An Archive of Stories: The Living Past**
– A poem that brings to life the stories waiting within archives, where each document holds ancestral echoes.

13. **The Solitary Genius Myth: Breaking the Illusion**
– Challenge the myth of the isolated artist, highlighting the interconnectedness of creativity and community.

14. **From Hollywood Props to Cultural Statements**
– Explore the transformation of ordinary objects into meaningful art, inspired by Red Star’s innovative sourcing.

15. **The Creative Window: Fear as a Motivator**
– Capture the moment of embracing fear as a driver for creativity, highlighting the transformative power of uncertainty.

 

And  a super simple summing up:

 

**What I Learned from Artist Wendy Red Star About Making Art**

People often think artists work alone in messy rooms, waiting for magical ideas. But Wendy Red Star, a famous artist, shows us that this isn’t true. Her art teaches us five important things about being creative:

1. **Fake Things Can Be Real in Art**
Wendy made art with fake grass and toy animals because she didn’t have much money. She wanted to show how things are made today. Her art is like a special dress from her tribe that used fake teeth when real ones were hard to find. So, using pretend stuff can still be important and real.

2. **Limits Help You Create**
People think artists need lots of time and freedom, but Wendy found that having less time made her work harder and better. She was a mom with a job, so she made art at night. Later, she lost her job but decided to try being a full-time artist. It was scary, but she worked hard and succeeded.

3. **Thinking is Part of Making Art**
Wendy doesn’t just make art in her studio. She spends a lot of time thinking and researching on her computer. This helps her come up with great ideas before she starts creating. Thinking is an important part of making art, even if you can’t see it.

4. **Working with Others is Important**
At first, Wendy worked by herself. But she learned that working with other people makes her art even better. She now enjoys working with different people to create new things, and she wishes young artists knew that it’s okay to get help.

5. **Learning from the Past**
Wendy learns about her ancestors by looking at old things in museums. She uses these stories in her art, like when she found out about a chief from her tribe who liked a famous house and made his home look like it. Wendy’s research is like talking to her ancestors.

**Conclusion: Finding Your Own Way**
Wendy Red Star shows us that making art isn’t just about being alone and waiting for ideas. It’s about using what you have, thinking a lot, working with others, and learning from the past. She teaches us to find our own special way of being creative. So, what ideas about making art do you need to forget to follow your dreams?

Created with theoasis.com

And a video take on the above: