Attendez! If a #Netnarr Fell in the Forest & No Network Heard It…

 

Attendez!

I was reading Daniel Bassill’s comment to my post about signal & noise and wondering why it had taken me so long to get back to it. I almost always attend to the business of reciprocating with folks who have honored me with their attention. I had not done so for Daniel F. Bassill . He has been kind, gentle and considerate in responding over the years to my posts. Sorry, Dan. I promise to do better.

I replied to his comment

Yes. The wheat from chaff problem. How do we decide what needs attending and what doesn’t? We need filters to do this initial pass at the noise. Questions are a way to do that. I teach my students that research questions are their only hope if they want to carry on in the face of the digital world. Other filters include personal interest or what used to be called curiosity. Passion might be another. Categories would be another of these filters. Creating filters is job one for anyone hoping to help others learn the knowledge biz. So, as much as we hate the dismissal, tl;dr is a legitimate filter. A more interesting observation, I think, is the one you make: the massive amounts of information flowing from the simplest of possibilia, a tweet or a blog post with links or… I would love to know the decision-making process behind your Facebook friend’s tl;dr. Was it a gut decision or a conscious and rational decision tree at work? How do we decide what to attend to and what not to attend to? Thanks for helping me come up with this intriguing question, Dan.

I have had a similar issue with #netnarr, the networked narrative MOOC sponsored by Alan Levine and Mia Zamora. I hit the ground running well before the course started then school began and I had to back off to attend to classes. I lost my way in an ever-rising tide of tweets about alchemy and daily do-this-and-do-that (#dtdt). And when I did try to play the game, to ante up with creative posts about identity and origin stories and psychological alchemy like this one. I got none fucks given. It was my own fault. I don’t even follow my own credo.

I needed to engage.

Did I engage? No, I pulled away. So,  I draw back in with my credo above in hand (or heart). I try again. I am Boxer in Animal Farm, filled with the surety that all I have to do is try harder for a different result. You can see how I am of two minds here: step away and let go or bear down and keep on.


Boxer (Animal Farm) – Created with Haiku Deck, presentation software that inspires

(Point of Information:  The embed above about Boxer was created using Wikipedia and Zuru, a HaikuDeck semi-bot for creating presentations.  Took five minutes to make.  1. Find Wikipedia page, 2. Import into Zuru, 3. Decide on a few piz to go along with preselected text, 4. Create deck. )

What Does It Mean and So What?

Having read Maha Bali’s post about fake news, I am beginning to think that her analysis is a good start, but it doesn’t go far enough. The real problem for me is how to perform an initial filter on information that is coming in. Doing this might include some of Maha’s suggestions, but a quick look at how much even her short post requires of the reader might indicate something else is the matter in Internetland.

Here is a link to a site where I gathered all the links from the original post. You, too, can be amazed at how much abides in a humble post and its links.

I used a Chrome browser extension called (LinkGrabber) to gather all of the ‘relevant’ links on her post and then I spidered out one level from the hyperlinks on her original post to gather even more links from those secondary level posts. LinkGrabber vacuums up every link on a page so I exercised my own judgement in deciding which ones to keep and which to leave. I got rid of at least as many or more than I kept.

Here is the page that has all of the links I kept .

From the moment I began reading her post I did not so much agree or disagree with her analysis as much as be convinced that there was a rhinoceros peeing in the room. What I refer to is our massive expectation for the reader, especially the naive one. Is it any wonder that folks rarely comment or annotate or otherwise reciprocate? What we are asking of our readers is unprecedented. Way before we even get to the issue of truth, post-truth, fakity, or truthiness, we have got to figure out how to source the signal.

For example, if you are a serious close reader there are over 200 calls to read in the primary source(Maha’s original post) as well as secondary ones posts she links to). In fact there is so much information in these links that getting to the content and whether it is accurate, persuasive, logically sound, and fair, (the whole panoply of crap-detecting wetware we apply to the post itself) is it any wonder that my students tend to filter out almost everything?

I was agog at the Amazon affiliate links. They have over 500 other links inside the Amazon page they point to. I know that no one reads those links. Most aren’t even aware that they exist, but how do we actually approach those pages in order to make sense of them? Do we use these same real life sense- making ‘functions’ and decision filtering trees as we read Maha’s post? I don’t think so. We approach that Amazon page with very clear purposes as reader. We ignore almost everything because we can safely ignore most of it. I want to teach my readers how to ignore almost everything that needs to be ignored. Or to put it like Elmore Leonard might have, “When you read, try to leave out all the parts the writers should have skipped.”

And this is just one, modest post trying to draw out a signal in the simoom of noise that we self-generate. The initial problem is not discerning fake facts, rather it is in deciding which is the signal and which the noise. I need more and better tools for parsing this sheep from those goats and this wheat from that chaff.

I am going to open my writing classes this semester with an exercise using LinkGrabber. I hope it opens my students’ eyes to the rising tide of information that stands to sweep them away. I am looking for other tools to help them do this in such a way that they are left with only the best information. Then we will work on whether it is fake or not. Perhaps there will be some initial parsing of essays that will involve standard vetting of texts like verifying the author’s cred, fact-checking, and doing an initial fairness scan.

Thanks to Maha for her original article. And to her sources as well. I am doing a lot of thinking out loud here, but I am really struck by the need to gather information in an intelligent, filtered way and then vetting it for any truth/Truth/Post-truth/truthiness I can wring out of it. Wish us luck. If my teaching is as “all-over-the-place” as my writing here, we are going to need it.