Reading Mike Rose, Lives on the Boundaries


Thoughts on thank you notes and the Western Canon

The thank you note is part of the Western canon of writing. It plays into the hierarchy of respect we pay, right or wrong, to all canonical writing.  If you are part of the canon, then you have paid your dues and are worthy of respect.  But thank you notes have many other forms, we just valorize the written note.

The haptic, hand-to-hand version of this form has largely died. Why? Is it because it has been supplanted by a digital version?  I don’t really know, but I don’t see digital thank you letters very much. And by that I mean texts, like email thank you’s, that very much ape what the old thank you notes did . I don’t see these in my own professional life except from my peers who valorize these same canonical texts.

My students rarely write them even though I am a stout advocate in my classes as part of any network building exercise. But what if they do exist. What if I just don’t see them.

Students come to class without my canonical, Pavlovian triggers. Perhaps students recommend your class as a thank you and not as a sign that you are an “easy” teacher. Or they signal their pleasure via sites like ProfEval. Maybe students fill out voluntary evaluations for university classes of their own accord as a thank you. Or they leave you notes on your door that they have dropped by. Could that be a thank you? Students risk telling a counter-narrative in class. Is that a thank you to the teacher for providing a safe place to take that risk? Does any time they give you attention whether it is in class or out or online, is that a thank you? My point is that the non-canonical ‘thank you’ is likely quite invisible to those of us who have bought into the canon.  

As an aside, I just have to ask at this point, “What has the canon brought us to and where?” If you are the least observant human on the planet, you can’t help notice that what “our Canon” has brought us is our philosophy of planetary dominion, capitalism, climate change, war, racism and all the other ism’s.  We are where we are because of the Western Canon.  How can this domination and responsibility be denied? Who in their right minds would argue for more of the same when there is an indigenous canon, local and distributed in a decentralized way that we have de-valorized, de-valued, and denied that might have proven way more sustainable?

Changing that is the challenge of the ‘end times’ of my career. This strikes me as a burden of blind spots and at the same time a joy of discovery in the face of that. And by joy I also mean the pain of discovery.

All my thinking on this has been inspired by a second reading of Mike Rose’s Lives on the Boundaries.  I am meeting with faculty this week to discuss how to re-imagine a classroom filled with ‘underprepared’ students.  I have got to turn this around to a discussion of how to re-imagine a classroom filled with learners who come to university for the first time with an existing set of unacknowledged literacies as well as a need to learn some new ones.  We have got to be able to pivot from the standard focus on literacy deficits to ones of literacy surpluses and back again.  We need to figure out how to learn new literacies via the old ones and vice versa.  If we don’t, then all of the problems we have now will only grow. This growth will be reduced to matters of relevance in a very costly learning ecosystem.  Universities are already losing the battle for relevance. Just check out enrollment at universities like mine where enrollment is hemorrhaging.

I had a recent blog post here where I tried to thank my anonymous online class reader by using a poetry and video remix. I have gotten no response from my ‘thank you’. I think that attending to and honoring other’s work by remixing is a powerful thank you message. To others that might still be a blind spot that just feels weird at first and for perhaps for the first few times it happens, but I think this thank you comes from a larger place: attention must be paid. That is the coin of the realm now. It could just become the newest addition to a much expanded canon. I hope so.


Feldgangs 4 All: Walks in the Pastures of Attention

I borrowed the term ‘feldgang’ from Otto Scharmer. What he refers to on a literal level is simply a Sunday walk in the family farm pastures and fields with no intent other than to woolgather (That is an etymological gem we won’t explore here for the moment.) Figuratively, it can mean any “field”. For example, your field can be a website. That is how I am using that metaphorically in this post.

The field in this case is being made real by a tool, Webrecorder. With that tool you can record your footsteps, blazing a trail of sorts, in your own way. Folks can follow your trail even looking at the same videos and sound recordings and hyperlinks that you did. What use is this?

It all started with a plea for attention from my compadre, Kevin Hodgson.

This is a call to attend. Attend what? At a bare minimum Kevin asks us to check this out. You might be interested. In an attention ecology like Twitter, this is big ask. It means to drop what you are doing and do this. What I want to know is this? What do different folks consider reciprocation. In other words what is my duty here when my friend asks folks in a particular context to explore.

What I did is below? I think this combination of Webrecorder + Screencasting allows for a more careful reciprocal exercise. This is what it means to walk in the pastures of attention. At least, this is what it means to me. I would love to do something similar for a smaller pasture (a blog post with links) or something larger (Tweetdeck) that has different purposes to the feldgang.

For now, this is what I did in response to an ‘ask’ for attention, my feldgang.

So, I have set up the metes and bounds of the feldgang above. Below, I screencast my walk in the fields, some pasture, some hedgerow, some woods. Think of it as a director’s cut to the webrecording above.

And the coolest think of all is that you can upload the screencast to Vialogues for further analysis.  A group of teachers could get together, choose a common text, create a webrecording, do a screencast, and the analyze the video as a quick and dirty action research project.  I advocate for these kinds of collaboration because they lead to an appreciation of how we direct each other to attend in different ways for different purposes.  Perhaps that could be a filter to getting us all to think more deeply about what we ask of others online.  I think this is classic solidarity building and understanding of knowledge as a commons.

 

Tacit Knowing: Local Knowledge and Local Kludges

I bought a new maul as my old Hults one needed some work and I didn’t want to have to do without. So I bought an SHW 6.6# maul from Earth Tools Garden Tools Catalog for a steal at $43.00. SHW is a German company that has been forging tools since 1267. I kid you not. That is not a misprint.

I always guard my axe and maul handles with hard rubber protectors, but for some reason nobody locally (including some very good Amish hardware stores) supplied them anymore. I am trying to minimize Amazon and online ordering as a way to reduce my own carbon footprint so I decided to make my own. I had done this before, but I always liked the simplicity of the hard rubber ones that slipped on and off so easily. Sigh.

Having recently finished James Howard Kunstler’s series of four books , A World Made by Hand,  I got a little more thoughtful.  Is this the kind of world he predicts? One where there are no more hardware stores with handle protectors and sure as hell ain’t no more online or Amazon?  Yes.  So…what do you do in this case. Make do or do without.

The image below has all the tools I used to fix this mess. I used them to repair my Hults maul as well. You can click on the image to get some concrete annotations about each item.

Roll yer own

Roll yer own

As a teacher I found myself woolgathering about a world made by hand where we spend most of our time and energy on learning how to survive.  What will happen to all of our academic and edutech castles if a slow crash came to be?   I think local knowledge and local fixes take over.  We muddle through.  Do educational institutions know how to muddle through anymore?  Some do and some don’t. Most don’t and are already feeling the pressure in ways they can’t understand and can’t adapt to.  I suppose it all depends on what Kunstler asks, “Is it a slow crash or an apocalypse?”

I am no prepper. I hate how they appear to have already abandoned humanity.  Just consider the Silicon Valley moguls who think that the apocalypse is just another contingency to be prepared for.  Yeah, they were never in it for anyone but themselves, these sons and daughters of Ayn Rand.  Here’s a broad brush of this future.

Schools for reading and writing will survive. Universities will fail en masse.  Tools and the capacity to make tools will rule. Books will become treasure.  I have a whole wall of them, many written over 50 years ago. Of course, I could be wrong, but it is amazing where one’s woolgatherings can lead as one makes do with local knowledge and materials. Amazing.