Queering the Pitch: Hacking Can’t Mean Everything

Pretty gnarly work summing a week of this work, but you did it, Kevin. Grand job.  Everyone should take a look at dogtrax’ reflection on Week Four of #CLMOOC. I feel a need to do some ‘splainin’.  I spent a good bit of my time this week proclaiming my ignorance, #flailing was my hashtag for it.  I did not understand how the word hack could mean what our facilitators said it meant.  Particularly I could not understand how one could hack one’s own writing, an act of self-plagiarism.  I felt that the #CLMOOC  pitch was queered.

In fact, I came to several conclusions about hacking this week that have almost nothing to do with writing but everything to do with power.

Hacking is both anabolic and catabolic, black hat and white hat.  We acknowledge the one and discourage the other, yet they both derive their strength from a single source–the need for power and personal agency.  And because learning is about power I think we need to not only teach the use of hacking layers like X-Ray Goggles that Kevin writes about,  but we need to acknowledge the need that makes tools like that feel so good.  X-Ray Goggles amounts to defacing another’s site, Zeegas amount to theft without attribution, animated gifs…well what exactly are they but plagiarizing the commons.

As writers we owe it to ourselves to empower our readers and part of that is ’embracing the suck’ that we so cavalierly call the dark side of hacking.  We need to acknowledge that hacking often is quite beyond being ‘a little subversive’ and that if we do empower our learners much as we do our readers, then chaos might be the result.  And that won’t work in most of our schools even with a wink and a nod from Caesar.

This is uncomfortable.  Empowerment is double-edged.  We all know it.  I got a bit incensed this week when I felt we weren’t giving the word ‘hack’ its due. We were watering it down, dumbing down its rich connotations.  That word is an instrument of power first, last and always.  To call it something else just hacked me off.  It made me go back and reread Orwell’s essay “Politics and the English Language” (http://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/politics/english/e_polit). Orwell argues against the  “staleness of imagery.”–yeah, Amen, George. I hates me a dead metaphor,too.  The other no-no in his mind is “lack of precision.” I suppose that is what I have been struggling with all week, the belief that the word can be all things to all people.

I include in “lack of precision” the stripping away of a word’s major connotations and denotations in order to use it for other purposes.  And what might those purposes be?  Glomming onto a trend, appearing to be in the educational know, mollifying our audiences by appealing to the pop culture zeitgeist…of seeking motives both negative and positive there is no end, but you’d better believe Pearson is trying to figure out a way to make a buck off the hacking the Maker Movement.  That is the corruption of language that starts with imprecision.  Or so sayeth the man.

I agree along with Kevin that “the words will follow” but will those who follow with those words be as pure of heart as we are ;)?  I know I can be hyperbolic, that is a rhetorical styling that my college composition instructor called my tendency toward the “purple and the prolix”, but I won’t hesitate to call out the Emperors of Language who wear no words.

Ian O’Byrne and the Pursuit of Fresh Snark

In my continuing attempts to play, I saw that Ian was in need of heeding.  He wanted to let loose his game chops on the whole “Facebook experimenting on all its users without external supervision” deal.  I wanted to help in some small way that also entered into the spirit of play that embues #CLMOOC this week. So we did an ad hoc Google Hangout on Air.

Ian Lays Out a Snarky Plan

If you want to add to the plan you can to the YouTube and add comments or even better, make a trip to Vialogues and enter in the discussion there.

The Dark Side of Connection?

The interfaces that let users interact with connected objects are limited. But by analyzing data, they can predict the user’s next move.

 

Mavericks_Surf_Contest_2010b
Surfing. (2014, June 19). In Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Surfing&oldid=612532966

The interfaces that let users interact with connected objects are limited. But by analyzing data, they can predict the user’s next move.

Source: www.rudebaguette.com

How does the internet of things fit in with connected learning values and principles?  Every learner is working on objects/products/processes all the time.  They are in some ways already connected with digital tools, collaborations, publishing, editing–connected in public ways that are able to be connected further.

And then there are the unknown connections.  For example, in our #clmooc we have known knowns–all of our seen and foreseen digital spaces (hackpads, blogs, twitter, facebook, and G+ among others).  A few folks connect to most of these spaces that represent the first ripple of activity out from our MOOC.

ripples in color
File:Ripple effect on water.jpg – Wikimedia Commons. (n.d.). Retrieved June 23, 2014, from http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Ripple_effect_on_water.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

But no one sees all of this primary ripple.  For everyone there are known unknowns.  In other words we all admit to ourselves that we can’t and don’t see it all, connected to it all.  We know what we don’t know and we live with it.

Then there are the unknown knowns.  These are the lurkers. We know they exists because they sometimes flip the switch and become known to us via the primary ripples.  These are the nodes on a Twitter visualization who have been connected to by others who are a part of the primary ripple but are otherwise unknown to use and who, more importantly, may not know about #clmooc. Often these are folks we cite in links or folks we quote.  They are known to us in our MOOC context, but they likely do not know us in that context.

Then there are the unknown unknowns.  Common sense tells us that this category is like dark matter–ubiquitous and representing most of the universe.  It is just a fact that #clmooc is invisible to most of the world.  We are an unknown unknown to them. Humbling isn’t it?

This brings us to the content of the post–connected objects and their predictive value.  I think the radical takeaway is that as we move more fully into a world of connected object the unknown unknowns may be more predictable.  What I am talking about here is reducing complexity and using connected objects to do so.

You step on your Withings scale while brushing your teeth with your Kolibree tooth brush–you get a message on your smartwatch that you need to implement a moderate fasting regiment already estalished at your Google Health site. Or you need to take a bike to work which you find by saying, “Ok, Google, find me a public bike.”  Or so says the auteur Louis Dorard.

Where does this leave us who are helping folks learn?  In what ways will connected learning principles enhance or exacerbate this ultimate connectivity.  Dorard’s example of Disney’s Magic Band is especially instructive.  Will schools be less about physical connection in physical spaces and more about living in digital spaces with both human and artificially facilitators whose job will be to predictively eliminate all the unknown unknowns, known unknowns, and unknown knowns?  Will the world of predictive API’s in learning  be all about reducing the world into known knowns?

Connectivity, predictaby, cuts both ways.  If it adds to the collective complexity without reducing our signals to those in an echo chamber, I’m mostly OK with that.  But what if we are connected to every object we touch and every person we see and every idea we share,  what happens then?  This is not the scenario we have read in fiction and seen on screens.  This is fer realz. This is machine learning in a wet world.  And our MOOC is a part of it.  Of these categories, the philosopher Slavoj Žižek argues that the scariest is the unknown known.  These are the truths we already know but deny.  In the examples above we know that Acton’s Principle is a universal throughout human history- power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. This is demonstrable.  Separation of powers is the constitutional governance at the core of this universal.  Yet…technologies that connect and predict are given free and corruptible rein.

Personally, I agree with Nicholas Taleb that the unknown unknowns are potentially most revolutionary.  To me that means they are the most dangerous.  These “black swans”  emerge from the complexity of the world.  Taleb notes that before explorers went to Australia no one could have predicted  a black swan.  Then there they were, logically improbable.  I prefer another Taleb story, darker and truer for me.  It is the story of the turkey.  Is there anything in the turkey’s experience that would ever indicate to him that Thanksgiving Day would be any different than the days previous?  Thanksgiving Day is the black swan for every commercial turkey in the U.S.  What are the black swans of connectivity and connected learning?  Taleb  says we don’t know and, worse, it is impossible to know.  Unpredictable.   Charming.

tumblr_ltc12u4y3x1r2luwko1_400
soul mass transit system – This animated gif makes me happy. … (n.d.). Retrieved June 23, 2014, from http://aphonik.tumblr.com/post/11704182790/turkey